Except

The only one Error.

only available in nightly toolchain now.

Why?

The official error handling method of Rust is Result<T, E> where E: Error.

But Error is too complicated, various types need to be converted, and each crate has its own set of Error.

Even worse, enum nesting will occur, such as:

enum BazError {
    IO(std::io::Error),
}

enum BarError {
    IO(std::io::Error),
    Baz(BazError),
}

enum FooError {
    IO(std::io::Error),
    Bar(BarError),
}

How many times std::io::Error occurs here?

The anyhow::Error is good, but it is generally only used for application.

Solution

This is just a personal opinion.

An Error actually only contains the following elements:

• type: Auto generated id, used to determine whether the Error is a certain type.
• sub_type: Auto generated id, used to determine whether the Error is a certain sub type, used to supplement type.
• message: String describing the Error.
• data: Optional Error data.
• backtrace: Error call stack.
• source: Optional previous Error.

For Rust, the message, backtrace, source already exists in std::error::Error.

Then I prefer to auto generate the type, I think TypeId is a solution.

For data, I don't have the best idea, because it may be of any type. In order to achieve only one Error, I chose to use Box<dyn Any> internally to save it.

Example

use except::ErrorBuilder;

pub struct MyErrorKind;

pub fn foo() -> except::Result<()> {
    Err(ErrorBuilder::new::<MyErrorKind>().message("this is my error").build())
}

pub fn main() {
    if let Err(ex) = foo() {
        if ex.is::<MyErrorKind>() {
            eprintln!("my error detected: {:?}", ex);
        }
    }
}

License

Apache-2.0