cfi_types

CFI types for cross-language LLVM CFI support.

Installation

To install the cfi_types crate:

1. On a command prompt or terminal with your package root's directory as the current working directory, run the following command:

   cargo add cfi-types
   

Or:

1. Add the cfi_types crate to your package root's Cargo.toml file:

   [dependencies]
   cfi-types = "0.0.1"
   

2. On a command prompt or terminal with your package root's directory as the current working directory, run the following command:

   cargo fetch
   

Usage

To use the cfi_types crate:

1. Import the CFI types from the cfi_types crate. E.g.:

   use cfi_types::c_long;
   

2. Replace uses of C type aliases by CFI types. E.g.:

   extern "C" {
       fn func(arg: c_long);
   }
   
   fn main() {
       unsafe { func(c_long(5)) };
   }
   

Background

Type metadata

LLVM uses type metadata to allow IR modules to aggregate pointers by their types. This type metadata is used by LLVM CFI to test whether a given pointer is associated with a type identifier (i.e., test type membership).

Clang uses the Itanium C++ ABI's virtual tables and RTTI typeinfo structure name as type metadata identifiers for function pointers.

For cross-language LLVM CFI support, a compatible encoding must be used. The compatible encoding chosen for cross-language LLVM CFI support is the Itanium C++ ABI mangling with vendor extended type qualifiers and types for Rust types that are not used across the FFI boundary (see Type metadata in the design document).

Encoding C integer types

Rust defines char as an Unicode scalar value, while C defines char as an integer type. Rust also defines explicitly-sized integer types (i.e., i8, i16, i32, …), while C defines abstract integer types (i.e., char, short, long, …), which actual sizes are implementation defined and may vary across different data models. This causes ambiguity if Rust integer types are used in extern "C" function types that represent C functions because the Itanium C++ ABI specifies encodings for C integer types (e.g., char, short, long, …), not their defined representations (e.g., 8-bit signed integer, 16-bit signed integer, 32-bit signed integer, …).

For example, the Rust compiler currently is unable to identify if an

extern "C" {
    fn func(arg: i64);
}

Fig. 1. Example extern "C" function using Rust integer type.

represents a void func(long arg) or void func(long long arg) in an LP64 or equivalent data model.

For cross-language LLVM CFI support, the Rust compiler must be able to identify and correctly encode C types in extern "C" function types indirectly called across the FFI boundary when CFI is enabled.

For convenience, Rust provides some C-like type aliases for use when interoperating with foreign code written in C, and these C type aliases may be used for disambiguation. However, at the time types are encoded, all type aliases are already resolved to their respective ty::Ty type representations (i.e., their respective Rust aliased types), making it currently impossible to identify C type aliases use from their resolved types.

For example, the Rust compiler currently is also unable to identify that an

extern "C" {
    fn func(arg: c_long);
}

Fig. 2. Example extern "C" function using C type alias.

used the c_long type alias and is not able to disambiguate between it and an extern "C" fn func(arg: c_longlong) in an LP64 or equivalent data model.

Consequently, the Rust compiler is unable to identify and correctly encode C types in extern "C" function types indirectly called across the FFI boundary when CFI is enabled:

#include <stdio.h>
#include <stdlib.h>

// This definition has the type id "_ZTSFvlE".
void
hello_from_c(long arg)
{
    printf("Hello from C!\n");
}

// This definition has the type id "_ZTSFvPFvlElE"--this can be ignored for the
// purposes of this example.
void
indirect_call_from_c(void (*fn)(long), long arg)
{
    // This call site tests whether the destination pointer is a member of the
    // group derived from the same type id of the fn declaration, which has the
    // type id "_ZTSFvlE".
    //
    // Notice that since the test is at the call site and is generated by Clang,
    // the type id used in the test is encoded by Clang.
    fn(arg);
}

Fig. 3. Example C library using C integer types and Clang encoding.

use std::ffi::c_long;

#[link(name = "foo")]
extern "C" {
    // This declaration would have the type id "_ZTSFvlE", but at the time types
    // are encoded, all type aliases are already resolved to their respective
    // Rust aliased types, so this is encoded either as "_ZTSFvu3i32E" or
    // "_ZTSFvu3i64E", depending to what type c_long type alias is resolved to,
    // which currently uses the u<length><type-name> vendor extended type
    // encoding for the Rust integer types--this is the problem demonstrated in
    // this example.
    fn hello_from_c(_: c_long);

    // This declaration would have the type id "_ZTSFvPFvlElE", but is encoded
    // either as "_ZTSFvPFvu3i32ES_E" (compressed) or "_ZTSFvPFvu3i64ES_E"
    // (compressed), similarly to the hello_from_c declaration above--this can
    // be ignored for the purposes of this example.
    fn indirect_call_from_c(f: unsafe extern "C" fn(c_long), arg: c_long);
}

// This definition would have the type id "_ZTSFvlE", but is encoded either as
// "_ZTSFvu3i32E" or "_ZTSFvu3i64E", similarly to the hello_from_c declaration
// above.
unsafe extern "C" fn hello_from_rust(_: c_long) {
    println!("Hello, world!");
}

// This definition would have the type id "_ZTSFvlE", but is encoded either as
// "_ZTSFvu3i32E" or "_ZTSFvu3i64E", similarly to the hello_from_c declaration
// above.
unsafe extern "C" fn hello_from_rust_again(_: c_long) {
    println!("Hello from Rust again!");
}

// This definition would also have the type id "_ZTSFvPFvlElE", but is encoded
// either as "_ZTSFvPFvu3i32ES_E" (compressed) or "_ZTSFvPFvu3i64ES_E"
// (compressed), similarly to the hello_from_c declaration above--this can be
// ignored for the purposes of this example.
fn indirect_call(f: unsafe extern "C" fn(c_long), arg: c_long) {
    // This indirect call site tests whether the destination pointer is a member
    // of the group derived from the same type id of the f declaration, which
    // would have the type id "_ZTSFvlE", but is encoded either as
    // "_ZTSFvu3i32E" or "_ZTSFvu3i64E", similarly to the hello_from_c
    // declaration above.
    //
    // Notice that since the test is at the call site and is generated by the
    // Rust compiler, the type id used in the test is encoded by the Rust
    // compiler.
    unsafe { f(arg) }
}

// This definition has the type id "_ZTSFvvE"--this can be ignored for the
// purposes of this example.
fn main() {
    // This demonstrates an indirect call within Rust-only code using the same
    // encoding for hello_from_rust and the test at the indirect call site at
    // indirect_call (i.e., "_ZTSFvu3i32E" or "_ZTSFvu3i64E").
    indirect_call(hello_from_rust, 5);

    // This demonstrates an indirect call across the FFI boundary with the Rust
    // compiler and Clang using different encodings for hello_from_c and the
    // test at the indirect call site at indirect_call (i.e., "_ZTSFvu3i32E" or
    // "_ZTSFvu3i64E" vs "_ZTSFvlE").
    //
    // When using rustc LTO (i.e., -Clto), this works because the type id used
    // is from the Rust-declared hello_from_c, which is encoded by the Rust
    // compiler (i.e., "_ZTSFvu3i32E" or "_ZTSFvu3i64E").
    //
    // When using (proper) LTO (i.e., -Clinker-plugin-lto), this does not work
    // because the type id used is from the C-defined hello_from_c, which is
    // encoded by Clang (i.e., "_ZTSFvlE").
    indirect_call(hello_from_c, 5);

    // This demonstrates an indirect call to a function passed as a callback
    // across the FFI boundary with the Rust compiler and Clang using different
    // encodings for the hello_from_rust_again and the test at the indirect call
    // site at indirect_call_from_c (i.e., "_ZTSFvu3i32E" or "_ZTSFvu3i64E" vs
    // "_ZTSFvlE").
    //
    // When Rust functions are passed as callbacks across the FFI boundary to be
    // called back from C code, the tests are also at the call site but
    // generated by Clang instead, so the type ids used in the tests are encoded
    // by Clang, which do not match the type ids of declarations encoded by the
    // Rust compiler (e.g., hello_from_rust_again). (The same happens the other
    // way around for C functions passed as callbacks across the FFI boundary to
    // be called back from Rust code.)
    unsafe {
        indirect_call_from_c(hello_from_rust_again, 5);
    }
}

Fig. 4. Example Rust program using Rust integer types and the Rust compiler encoding.

Whenever there is an indirect call across the FFI boundary or an indirect call to a function passed as a callback across the FFI boundary, the Rust compiler and Clang use different encodings for C integer types for function definitions and declarations, and at indirect call sites when CFI is enabled (see Figs. 3–4).

The cfi_types crate

To solve the encoding C integer types problem, this crate provides a new set of C types as user-defined types using the cfi_encoding attribute and repr(transparent) to be used for cross-language LLVM CFI support.

use cfi_types::c_long;

#[link(name = "foo")]
extern "C" {
    // This declaration has the type id "_ZTSFvlE" because it uses the CFI types
    // for cross-language LLVM CFI support. The cfi_types crate provides a new
    // set of C types as user-defined types using the cfi_encoding attribute and
    // repr(transparent) to be used for cross-language LLVM CFI support. This
    // new set of C types allows the Rust compiler to identify and correctly
    // encode C types in extern "C" function types indirectly called across the
    // FFI boundary when CFI is enabled.
    fn hello_from_c(_: c_long);

    // This declaration has the type id "_ZTSFvPFvlElE" because it uses the CFI
    // types for cross-language LLVM CFI support--this can be ignored for the
    // purposes of this example.
    fn indirect_call_from_c(f: unsafe extern "C" fn(c_long), arg: c_long);
}

// This definition has the type id "_ZTSFvlE" because it uses the CFI types for
// cross-language LLVM CFI support, similarly to the hello_from_c declaration
// above.
unsafe extern "C" fn hello_from_rust(_: c_long) {
    println!("Hello, world!");
}

// This definition has the type id "_ZTSFvlE" because it uses the CFI types for
// cross-language LLVM CFI support, similarly to the hello_from_c declaration
// above.
unsafe extern "C" fn hello_from_rust_again(_: c_long) {
    println!("Hello from Rust again!");
}

// This definition also has the type id "_ZTSFvPFvlElE" because it uses the CFI
// types for cross-language LLVM CFI support, similarly to the hello_from_c
// declaration above--this can be ignored for the purposes of this example.
fn indirect_call(f: unsafe extern "C" fn(c_long), arg: c_long) {
    // This indirect call site tests whether the destination pointer is a member
    // of the group derived from the same type id of the f declaration, which
    // has the type id "_ZTSFvlE" because it uses the CFI types for
    // cross-language LLVM CFI support, similarly to the hello_from_c
    // declaration above.
    unsafe { f(arg) }
}

// This definition has the type id "_ZTSFvvE"--this can be ignored for the
// purposes of this example.
fn main() {
    // This demonstrates an indirect call within Rust-only code using the same
    // encoding for hello_from_rust and the test at the indirect call site at
    // indirect_call (i.e., "_ZTSFvlE").
    indirect_call(hello_from_rust, c_long(5));

    // This demonstrates an indirect call across the FFI boundary with the Rust
    // compiler and Clang using the same encoding for hello_from_c and the test
    // at the indirect call site at indirect_call (i.e., "_ZTSFvlE").
    indirect_call(hello_from_c, c_long(5));

    // This demonstrates an indirect call to a function passed as a callback
    // across the FFI boundary with the Rust compiler and Clang the same
    // encoding for the hello_from_rust_again and the test at the indirect call
    // site at indirect_call_from_c (i.e., "_ZTSFvlE").
    unsafe {
        indirect_call_from_c(hello_from_rust_again, c_long(5));
    }
}

Fig. 5. Example Rust program using Rust integer types and the Rust compiler encoding with the cfi_types crate types.

This new set of C types allows the Rust compiler to identify and correctly encode C types in extern "C" function types indirectly called across the FFI boundary when CFI is enabled (see Fig 5).

Contributing

See CONTRIBUTING.md.

License

Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 or the MIT License. See LICENSE-APACHE or LICENSE-MIT for license text and copyright information.